Paradise Papers data dump exposes offshore holdings of world’s elite
OTTAWA -- The Canada Revenue Agency says it won't hesitate to investigate new evidence of offshore tax evasion in the wake of a second massive leak of tax haven financial records.
The leak of some 13.4 million records, dubbed the Paradise Papers, lifts another veil on the often murky ways in which the wealthy – including more than 3,000 Canadian individuals and entities – stash their money in offshore accounts to avoid paying taxes.
Among the names that pop up in the records with some connection to offshore accounts are former Canadian prime ministers Brian Mulroney, Paul Martin and Jean Chretien, the Queen, U.S. commerce secretary Wilbur Ross, and the past and current chief fundraisers for the federal Liberal party.
Chretien denied having an offshore account via a statement on Monday.
"Any news report that suggests I have or ever had or was associated in any way with any offshore account is false," Chretien said in the statement. "While as a lawyer for Heenan Blaikie I did some work for Madagascar Oil as a client of the law firm, all fees were billed by the law firm and went to the law firm. I never received any share options and I never had a bank account outside Canada.”
Neither the CRA nor any court has determined the Canadians did anything wrong.
“It’s a bit rich to be chasing small business people and farmers, and professionals and doctors and lawyers when the upper 0.1 per cent is making use of these tax havens,” said Richard Leblanc, a professor of corporate governance at York University, in an interview with BNN Monday.
Offshore accounts are used by wealthy individuals and corporations around the world as a perfectly legal way to reduce their tax burden, although the anonymity provided to account holders has also led to associations with tax evasion, money laundering and organized crime.
The Paradise Papers were obtained by German newspaper Suddeutsche Zeitung and the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists, including CBC/Radio Canada and the Toronto Star, which published details on Sunday.
The media outlets did not disclose how they acquired the documents, which consist primarily of client records of offshore law firm Appleby, as well as some records from offshore corporate services firms Estera and Asiaciti Trust.
In an apparent attempt to pre-empt the news reports, the CRA issued a statement late on Friday, detailing the agency's efforts to crack down on tax evasion and tax avoidance, which intensified following the first huge leak of tax-haven records, known as the Panama Papers, in April 2016.
Leblanc called the Paradise Papers a “gift” to the Canada Revenue Agency.
“It’s beneficial [for the CRA] because they now have a line of sight to what the mind and management was, truly, as opposed to legal disclosure -- which often in Caribbean countries you have a numbered company, you have a shell company, you have opaque disclosure” he said. “What this does is it opens the komono, if you will, for what is actually happening.”
The agency said it has invested $1 billion to tackle the problem and currently has more than 990 audits and more than 42 criminal investigations underway related to offshore tax havens.
As a result of audits over the last two years, the CRA said it identified some $25 billion in unpaid taxes, interest and penalties. And last year, it levied more than $44 million in penalties on tax advisers who facilitated non-compliance with Canadian tax laws.
The agency said it's also working closely with 36 other countries in the Joint International Taskforce on Shared Intelligence and Collaboration on more effective ways to detect and deal with tax evasion and avoidance.
The CRA also promised to do more should new details of questionable practices emerge.
"In the event that further details come to light, CRA will not hesitate to investigate and take further action as warranted," the agency said.
"The government of Canada will continue to work with the provinces and territories, as well as other tax administrations and all other partners, to ensure a tax system that works for Canadians. In addition, the CRA will continue to build on its capacity to detect and crack down on tax cheats and ensure that those who choose to break the law face the consequences and are held accountable for their actions."
Are you confident the Canada Revenue Agency is doing enough to crack down on offshore tax evasion?
A spokesman for National Revenue Minister Diane Lebouthillier, said on Sunday that "the CRA is reviewing links to Canadian entities and will take appropriate action in regards to the Paradise Papers."
Tax avoidance measures involving offshore trusts are legal, provided that the trust is genuinely managed offshore and that Canadian taxes are paid on any Canadian contributions.
According to the Toronto Star and CBC/Radio Canada, the records suggest that Stephen Bronfman and his family's Montreal-based investment company, Claridge Inc., were linked to an offshore trust in the Cayman Islands that may have used questionable means to avoid paying millions in taxes.
Bronfman is a close friend of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who tapped him in 2013 to fill the role of revenue chair -- effectively, the chief fundraiser -- for the federal Liberal party.
In a statememnt released Monday, Bronfman said he and his family "have always conducted themselves in accordance with the highest legal and ethical standards."
"Stephen Bronfman has never funded nor used offshore trusts," the statement read. "His Canadian trusts have paid all taxes on all their income to the Canadian Government."
The offshore trust also involved former chief Liberal fundraiser and senator Leo Kolber and his son, Jonathan Kolber.
William Brock, a lawyer for Bronfman and Jonathan Kolber, denied any impropriety, telling the CBC that his clients "have always acted properly and ethically, including fully complying with all applicable laws." Any suggestion of "false documentation, fraud, 'disguised' conduct, tax evasion or similar conduct is false," Brock added.
The Prime Minister's Office referred questions about Bronfman to the Liberal party.
Party spokesman Braeden Caley said Bronfman's role is strictly a volunteer position devoted to fundraising, "not policy decisions." The revenue chair is a "non-voting position" on the party's national board, Caley added.
Conservative leader Andrew Scheer issued a statement on Sunday accusing Trudeau of failing to crack down on "tax avoidance schemes used by his wealthy friends."
"Justin Trudeau's well-connected Liberal friends get away with paying less, and you pay more. There is nothing fair about that," the statement said.
-- With files from BNN